Choosing between contactors in the relays, contactors, and industrial switches category comes down to what the contactor does for your motor circuit. One product bundles overload protection into the same unit; the other is a lean, single-pole switching device at a much lower price. Here's how the Advance Control Motor Contactor & Overload and the Packard 1 Pole 30 Amp 24V Contactor Pr4013 compare so you can pick the right one.
Quick Verdict
The Advance Control Motor Contactor & Overload ($114.85) is the pick when you want switching and motor protection in a single device. The Packard 1 Pole 30 Amp 24V Contactor Pr4013 ($27.59) is the pick when you need a no-nonsense contactor for a standard control circuit and you want to keep the cost down.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Product | Price | Best For | Key Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advance Control Motor Contactor & Overload | $114.85 | Motors that need integrated overload protection | Contactor and overload relay in one unit |
| Packard 1 Pole 30 Amp 24V Contactor Pr4013 | $27.59 | Simple 30-amp single-pole switching | 1-pole, 30A, 24V coil, spade terminals |
The $87.26 difference is the clearest signal that these are aimed at different jobs. The Advance is a combined protection and switching device; the Packard is a bare-bones contactor for a specific control voltage.
Where the Advance Wins
Choose the Advance when your panel design calls for a contactor that also handles motor protection. Instead of wiring a separate relay, you get a device that combines both functions. That can simplify the layout and reduce the number of components you have to mount and connect. For an industrial setup where downtime is costly, having protection already in the contactor is a meaningful advantage.
Where the Packard Wins
The Packard is the better pick when you're repairing an existing control circuit and want a straightforward replacement. The spade terminals make wiring easy, and the price is far lower than the Advance.
Product Notes
Advance Control Motor Contactor & Overload
The strongest reason to choose this device is the integration: you get the switching function and overload protection in one package, which cuts down on panel wiring and simplifies spares. It's a new unit from Advance. The main limitation is the higher price; if your system already uses a separate motor starter with overload protection, this product's protection feature is redundant. For a fresh installation where you want everything in one spot, though, it's a clean solution.
Packard 1 Pole 30 Amp 24V Contactor Pr4013
The Packard's appeal is its combination of price and practical specs. It's a new 1-pole, 30-amp contactor with a 24V coil, so it slots into many standard control circuits. The spade terminals are convenient for quick wiring, and the device is rated for systems up to 600VAC. The limitation is that a single pole only switches one line; if you're dealing with a multi-phase motor, you'll need multiple units or a different contactor.
Final Choice by Use Case
If you're building a new motor control panel and want overload protection without adding a separate relay, the Advance Control Motor Contactor & Overload is the natural choice. If you're replacing a failed contactor in an existing 24V circuit and the load is 30 amps or less, the Packard 1 Pole 30 Amp 24V Contactor Pr4013 gets the job done at a fraction of the cost.
