Choosing between soft starters and motor controls starts with your motor's phase and current draw. One product here is a used, industrial-grade starter for high-current work; the other is a new, compact module for smaller motors. That contrast drives the whole decision, and it explains why their prices are so far apart.
Quick Verdict
When your motor control decision sits between a heavy industrial starter and a compact module, the right pick comes down to your motor's power requirements. The Sprecher Schuh PCE-147-600V-120V is the heavy-duty item, bundled with a contactor. The LVSEDTAL SSR-40WA-R1 is the new, lightweight module for a smaller motor. At $999.99 versus $67.67, the price difference is dramatic, but so is the difference in what each product is built to handle.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Price | Condition | Motor Match | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sprecher Schuh PCXXE, PCE-147-600V-120V | $999.99 | Used | 147A, 3-phase, 120V coil | Includes Allen Bradley 100-E80KD00 contactor |
| LVSEDTAL SSR-40WA-R1 | $67.67 | New | 220V single-phase, 2kW/4kW/6kW/8kW | Assembly not required |
Where Each Product Wins
Choose the Sprecher Schuh PCE-147 when your project calls for a heavy-duty starter. Choose the LVSEDTAL module when you need a new, compact control module.
Product Notes
Sprecher Schuh PCXXE, PCE-147-600V-120V Motor Soft Starter 147A 3Phase 120V Coil
This is the unit to look at when your motor control job is serious industrial work. The product name spells out the critical numbers: 147A and a 120V coil, so it is meant for a specific kind of control panel. It is in used condition and was removed in working condition, which is a key consideration for this heavy-duty starter. The package also includes an Allen Bradley 100-E80KD00 contactor, giving you two interrelated components in one purchase. The limitation is the used status: you are buying a pre-owned industrial component, not a new unit, and that is worth factoring into your decision. If your motor needs the current and control voltage this starter is rated for, this is the one; if you are working on a smaller motor, it is oversized.
220V Single Phase Motor Soft Starter Module Controller 2KW4KW6KW8KW(SSR-40WA-R1
This module is built for the opposite situation: a 220V single-phase motor in the 2kW, 4kW, 6kW, or 8kW range. It is new and lightweight at 12.3 ounces, so it is a very different package from a big industrial starter. The title directly identifies the supported power range, so you can quickly check whether it fits your motor. Assembly is not required, which makes it a convenient choice for simpler installations. Where it falls short is the single-phase-only design; it is not intended for the high-current loads that the Sprecher Schuh starter handles. If your motor pulls high current, this module is not the right tool. For a small single-phase motor, it offers a compact soft-start solution.
Final Choice by Use Case
Choose the Sprecher Schuh PCE-147 when you need the heavy-duty starter. Choose the LVSEDTAL module when you want a new, compact unit for a smaller motor. If you are still deciding, start with your motor's phase and current draw; those two details will point you to the right product.
